Playoff Drought Among Cities with Pro Football and Baseball

Which cities with an NFL football team and a major league baseball team (there are 24 of them in the U.S.) have the longest droughts without a playoff win by the football team and a playoff appearance by the baseball team?

This list is updated as of January 2010, with the latest NFL playoff winners registered. It will be updated again after the 2010 major league baseball postseason qualifiers have earned their spots in September or October of 2010. Notes are below.

 

City

Years

NFL (last playoff win)

MLB (last playoff appearance)

Kansas City

40

Chiefs (1993)

Royals (1985)

Cincinnati

33

Bengals (1990)

Reds (1995)

Houston

22

Oilers (1991)

Astros (2005)

Detroit

21

Lions (1991)

Tigers (2006)

Pittsburgh

18

Steelers (2008)

Pirates (1992)

Cleveland

17

Browns (1994)

Indians (2007)

Miami

15

Dolphins (2000)

Marlins (2003)

San Francisco

13

49ers (2002)

Giants (2003)

Baltimore

12

Ravens (2009)

Orioles (1997)

Seattle

12

Seahawks (2007)

Mariners (2000)

Dallas

10

Cowboys (2009)

Rangers (1999)

Oakland

10

Raiders (2002)

A's (2006)

Atlanta

9

Falcons (2004)

Braves (2005)

Tampa-St. Petersburg

8

Buccaneers (2002)

Rays (2008)

St. Louis

5

Rams (2004)

Cardinals (2009)

Chicago

4

Bears (2006)

Cubs & White Sox (2008)

Denver

4

Broncos (2005)

Rockies (2009)

San Diego

4

Chargers (2008)

Padres (2006)

Milwaukee/Green Bay

3

Packers (2007)

Brewers (2008)

New York (2)

3

Jets (2009)

Mets (2006)

Boston

2

Patriots (2007)

Red Sox (2009)

New York (1)

2

Giants (2007)

Yankees (2009)

Phoenix

2

Cardinals (2009)

Diamondbacks (2007)

Philadelphia

1

Eagles (2008)

Phillies (2009)

Minneapolis

0

Vikings (2009)

Twins (2009)

Notes:

 

For baseball, mere appearance in the playoffs is considered here because it is harder to get in to begin with and easier to win at least one game in a series. For football, at least one playoff win is considered because it is easier to get in but harder to win at least one playoff game. Wins are counted in football also because, most times, getting into the divisional playoffs where four teams compete requires a wild-card win, whereas in baseball getting that wild-card win (to set the field of four playoff teams) essentially happens in the regular season in the wild-card race.

 

Houston's NFL team is now the Texans, though they have been in the league for such a short time. This is why the now-defunct Oilers are listed here for Houston's last pro football playoff win.

 

Washington is not on the list because the baseball Nationals have been in D.C. for such a short time and have never appeared in the playoffs. The last Redskins playoff win was in 2005.

 

The New York teams were divided into two pairs. This division is the result of the reasonable consideration of the football Giants and Yankees having been much more established by years, while the Jets and Mets both entered the pro ranks much later and at about the same time, 1960 and 1962 respectively.

 

Both the major league baseball clubs from Chicago, the Cubs and White Sox, earned a trip to the playoffs in 2008.

 

All locations are classified here as cities in contrast to considering them within their metropolitan area. (For instance, the "New England" Patriots are considered the team from Boston.) The notable exceptions are Milwaukee and Green Bay, and the Tampa-St. Petersburg teams which are both known as "Tampa Bay."

 

The second largest market in the country, Los Angeles, is not represented because it has no pro football team, though its baseball teams, the Dodgers and the Angels, regularly make the playoffs.

 

This page is designed to demonstrate that a team may be successful with a small market but terrific management, such as the Pittsburgh Steelers or Minnesota Twins. A team will also be successful with with any kind of management but have a distinct advantage of playing in a large market, such as the Philadelphia Eagles or New York Yankees.

 

It is competitive agony, however, for a team to have bad management and play in a small market. Behold Kansas City's Chiefs and Royals. Both clubs have suffered through notoriously inept front office management and a market that the media loathe having to showcase.

 

Kansas City's perpetually long misery is highlighted by the fact that two-thirds of the teams on this list have team-year playoff droughts that are at least one-third the length of Kansas City's. Its drought is twice as long as any other city's except Cincinnati, Houston, and Detroit. Just for comparison, here is Boston's playoff activity since the last Kansas City postseason victory (a period from 1993 to 2010): Patriots: 17 wins, Red Sox: 12 appearances (five championships between them). The Harry S Truman Sports Complex is the most barren place on the sports planet in October and January.

 

As if it can't be more excruciating, at the time of this writing (January 2010) the Chiefs just finished their season with a 4-12 record, and over the past three seasons have had a cumulative 10 wins and 38 losses. The Royals finished the '09 season again in the cellar of their division with the second worst record in the American League. Believe it or not, in the 1960's the Chiefs were truly in the elite class of pro football excellence, and the Royals were the same in the majors during the 1970's.

 

For another look at team success, go to Current Pro Sports Team Success.

 

NFL Team Names

 

Homepage  |  Site Map

 

 

 

This page was originally posted by David Beck at yourownjesus.net on October 8, 2009